You’ve probably seen recent media reports on the proposed changes to the guidelines for diagnosing Alzheimer’s, along with an article claiming that “a spinal fluid test can be 100 percent accurate in identifying patients with significant memory loss who are on their way to developing Alzheimer’s disease.” Today’s headlines include a story about a blood test for predicting whether you’ll develop Alzheimer’s.
Although most professionals are careful to say the proposed guidelines and tests aren’t ready for widespread use, public expectations seem very high. On a flight last month, I sat next to a man in his 20s whose stepfather is showing signs of memory loss. My seatmate wasn’t terribly concerned about his stepfather, he said, because he had seen the recent reports of progress in Alzheimer’s research and believed that a cure is around the corner.
Expecting Improved Diagnosis and Treatment

Mary Kay Baum
Two of my friends diagnosed with young onset dementia also have high expectations. They sent me their thoughts supporting the proposed guidelines for diagnosis, particularly the guidelines for a diagnosis of “preclinical Alzheimer’s.” Their strong support is based on the long and difficult process each went through to get diagnosis and treatment, and the relative success of treatments in stabilizing their conditions. It’s also based on their assumption that they would have been diagnosed with some form of Alzheimer’s if the proposed guidelines were used when they first sought answers about their symptoms.
“Consider me,” wrote Mary Kay Baum, who has a strong family history of dementia. “I am a 63 year-old woman who was a lawyer and pastor with two graduate degrees, thirty years of public service, and ten years of cognitive challenges. The old Alzheimer’s disease criteria ignored me. It did not have a vocabulary for my issues. Doctors did not know what to do with me! The criteria from 25 years ago did not advise practitioners to help me prevent the dementia we had seen in my mother and my aunt while in their mid-fifties. Most research excluded me…. Many in my situation fear we won’t be treated until we are really demented.”
Continue reading "The Trouble With Expectations" »